5
274 Goodman Street North B132, Rochester, NY 14607, USA
Rochester, New York 14607
+1 585-319-4314

If I could give them no stars I would because they messed up our wedding cake. We had agreed on vanilla and chocolate layers in the cake but only received vanilla. I remember even showing them a similar picture of the cake we wanted. We also agreed on different flavors for the cake layers and only got one standard flavor throughout. Very very disappointed in this very very dry cake.

The cupcakes here have always been great so this is the first place I thought of to order a custom cake for a special occasion. Extremely disappointed, the cake was supposed to be marble but cutting into it revealed it was all vanilla which wouldn't have been a big deal if it tasted good but it's just the point that it was not correct. More importantly the cake was rock hard more the consistency of tough dense bread rather than cake, it was difficult to even get a knife through through the frosting and embarrassingly when people were trying to eat pieces were literally being shot across the floor because the forks couldn't get through it to get a bite sized portion. It was like a dry brick with no flavor, I could not believe it, needless to say nearly the entire thing went in the garbage a huge disappointment and waste of money. Ended up buying a second cake from another store to try and make up for it.

We ordered their basic vanilla cake with vanilla cream frosting and strawberry filling for my son's birthday party. Unfortunately, the cake was dry inside and the frosting was too sweet. However their customer service was prompt and friendly.

Got here in the evening before closing. The staff was gracious and not rushing us at all. They took the time to introduce us to several different flavors of cupcakes on display. They had delicious samples of cookies at the counter. The cupcakes are your average size that you would make it home, but they taste amazing. My daughter had a PB&J cupcake, & I had a wonderful chocolate peanut butter. And I took my husband home a Boston cream. They were all wonderful. The prices are what you would expect her specialty cupcake, but definitely not the highest I've ever seen. Definitely worth scouting out.

I erased my original note, felt appropriate. Small local business' are not the enemy. Would delete entirely but Google does not give option. -Nicole

Show Map

Get Caked Bakery Inc — Bakery in Rochester

We are glad to greet you!

Get Caked Bakery Inc

Bakery at 274 Goodman Street North B132, Rochester, NY 14607, USA. Here you will find detailed information about Get Caked Bakery Inc: address, phone, fax, opening hours, customer reviews, photos, directions and more.

Opening hours

  • Monday
    12:00 – 6:00 PM
  • Tuesday
    12:00 – 9:00 PM
  • Wednesday
    12:00 – 9:00 PM
  • Thursday
    12:00 – 9:00 PM
  • Friday
    12:00 – 9:00 PM
  • Saturday
    10:00 AM – 7:00 PM
  • Sunday
    Closed

Rating

4
/
5
Based on 5 reviews

Contacts

Categories:
State:
New York
Address:
274 Goodman Street North B132, Rochester, NY 14607, USA.
City:
Rochester
Postcode:
14607

About Get Caked Bakery Inc

Get Caked Bakery Inc is a US Bakery based in Rochester, New York. Get Caked Bakery Inc is located at 274 Goodman Street North B132, Rochester, NY 14607, USA.


Please contact with Get Caked Bakery Inc using information above: Address, Phone number, Fax, Postal code, Website address, E-mail, Facebook. Find Get Caked Bakery Inc opening hours and driving directions or map. Find real customer reviews and ratings or write your own review.

Are you the owner?
You can make a change to the page:
Edit this page

ALL reviews about Get Caked Bakery Inc

  • Maya
    Added 2016.07.26
    If I could give them no stars I would because they messed up our wedding cake. We had agreed on vanilla and chocolate layers in the cake but only received vanilla. I remember even showing them a similar picture of the cake we wanted. We also agreed on different flavors for the cake layers and only got one standard flavor throughout. Very very disappointed in this very very dry cake.
  • Noah
    Added 2016.06.17
    The cupcakes here have always been great so this is the first place I thought of to order a custom cake for a special occasion. Extremely disappointed, the cake was supposed to be marble but cutting into it revealed it was all vanilla which wouldn't have been a big deal if it tasted good but it's just the point that it was not correct. More importantly the cake was rock hard more the consistency of tough dense bread rather than cake, it was difficult to even get a knife through through the frosting and embarrassingly when people were trying to eat pieces were literally being shot across the floor because the forks couldn't get through it to get a bite sized portion. It was like a dry brick with no flavor, I could not believe it, needless to say nearly the entire thing went in the garbage a huge disappointment and waste of money. Ended up buying a second cake from another store to try and make up for it.
  • Gabrielle
    Added 2014.03.05
    We ordered their basic vanilla cake with vanilla cream frosting and strawberry filling for my son's birthday party. Unfortunately, the cake was dry inside and the frosting was too sweet. However their customer service was prompt and friendly.
  • Hunter
    Added 2014.01.16
    Got here in the evening before closing. The staff was gracious and not rushing us at all. They took the time to introduce us to several different flavors of cupcakes on display. They had delicious samples of cookies at the counter. The cupcakes are your average size that you would make it home, but they taste amazing. My daughter had a PB&J cupcake, & I had a wonderful chocolate peanut butter. And I took my husband home a Boston cream. They were all wonderful. The prices are what you would expect her specialty cupcake, but definitely not the highest I've ever seen. Definitely worth scouting out.
  • Ashley
    Added 2013.09.30
    I erased my original note, felt appropriate. Small local business' are not the enemy. Would delete entirely but Google does not give option. -Nicole
Leave your own review about Get Caked Bakery Inc:
Add a review

Find Bakery in Rochester

Goodness Cakes Bakery Ltd
Bakery in New York
6 reviews
720 University Ave, Rochester, NY 14607, USA.
Malek S Brighton Bakery
Bakery in New York
6 reviews
1795 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14618, USA.
Premier Pastry
Bakery in New York
6 reviews
433 South Ave, Rochester, NY 14620, USA.
Baker Street Bakery
Bakery in New York
5 reviews
745 Park Ave, Rochester, NY 14607, USA.
Borinquen Bakery
Bakery in New York
5 reviews
1195 N Clinton Ave, Rochester, NY 14621, USA.
Cheesy Eddie S
Bakery in New York
5 reviews
602 South Ave, Rochester, NY 14620, USA.